19/23/24Musketeer · Sundowner · Sierra
beechcraftEffective Sep 28, 2026Timetable 1995–2026
What mechanics have reported to the FAA on the Beechcraft Musketeer, Sundowner and Sierra, the airworthiness directives in force, and the NTSB accident record, on one sheet. Model 19 Sport, 23 Musketeer and C23 Sundowner (fixed gear), and the retractable 24R Sierra.
Top six of ten systems. Counts reflect who reports, not how reliable the airplane is.
- Registered
- 1,515 in the U.S., FAA registry Sep 28, 2026
- Reports on file
- 258 since 1995
- 2016–2025
- 15, about 1 a year per 1,000 registered
- ADs in force
- 15 (2 airframe, 13 engine)
- Accidents
- 403 since 1995, 68 fatal
Airworthiness directives
15 in force · 5 superseded not shown
From Federal Register final rules since 1995. Whether an AD applies to a particular airplane depends on its serial number, engine and installed equipment; confirm against the FAA’s Dynamic Regulatory System.
AD99-05-13Effective Apr 19, 1999Raytheon Aircraft Company 17, 18, 19, 23, 24, 33, 35, 36/A36, A36TC/B36TC, 45, 50, 55, 56, 58, 58P, 58TC, 60, 65, 70, 76, 77, 80, 88, and 95 Series AirplanesOne-time
Some Raytheon aircraft experienced engine stoppage due to incorrect fuel selector positioning between detents. This AD requires installing a placard on the fuel tank selector to warn of the no-flow condition.
Read the AD in the Federal RegisterAD95-07-01Effective Apr 12, 1995Textron Lycoming O-360, LO-360, HO-360, HIO-360, TIO-360, LIO-360, AEIO-360, O-540, IO-540, TIO-540, LTIO-540, IVO-540, AEIO-540, TIO-541, and IO-720 Series Reciprocating EnginesOne-time
Unapproved connecting rod bolts sourced from Superior Air Parts, Inc., have failed in certain Textron Lycoming engines, potentially causing engine failure. The AD requires removing all suspect connecting rod bolts prior to further flight and replacing them with serviceable bolts.
Read the AD in the Federal RegisterAD2026-04-11Effective Apr 8, 2026Lycoming EnginesRepetitive
Certain connecting rod assemblies and bushings installed in Lycoming engines may fail due to inadequate design, potentially causing engine failure. This AD requires repetitive oil inspections for bronze particulates and replacement of affected connecting rod bushings with eligible parts.
Engine models named IO-360 series, O-320 series, O-360 series
Read the AD in the Federal RegisterAD2022-16-03Effective Aug 15, 2022Continental Aerospace Technologies, Inc., Lycoming Engines, and Textron Lycoming/Subsidiary of Textron, Inc. Reciprocating EnginesOne-time
Improperly lubricated roller bearings in certain S-1200 series magnetos may cause overheating and magneto seizure. This AD requires replacement of affected magnetos or inspection and component replacement if no white grease is detected.
Engine models named IO-346, IO-360, O-320, O-360
Read the AD in the Federal RegisterAD2020-25-12Effective Jan 15, 2021Superior Air Parts, Inc. Engines and Lycoming Engines Reciprocating Engines With a Certain SAP Crankshaft AssemblyOne-time
Three crankshaft assembly failures resulted in loss of engine power and emergency landings. This AD requires immediate removal from service of all affected SAP crankshaft assemblies.
Engine models named IO-360-B1A, IO-360-B1B, IO-360-B1D, IO-360-B1E, IO-360-B1F, IO-360-B2F, IO-360-L2A, IO-360-M1A, O-360, O-360-A1A, O-360-A1C, O-360-A1D
Read the AD in the Federal RegisterAD2015-19-07Effective Nov 3, 2015Lycoming Engines Fuel Injected Reciprocating EnginesRepetitive
Externally mounted fuel injector fuel lines on certain Lycoming fuel injected engines can fail, potentially causing uncontrolled engine fires and damage. This AD requires inspection and replacement if necessary of fuel injector fuel lines with proper clamping.
Engine models named IO-360-A1A, IO-360-A1B, IO-360-A1B6, IO-360-A1B6D, IO-360-A1C, IO-360-A1D, IO-360-A1D6, IO-360-A2A, IO-360-A2B, IO-360-A3B6, IO-360-A3B6D, IO-360-B1B
Read the AD in the Federal RegisterAD2009-22-03Effective Nov 12, 2009Hartzell Propeller Inc. ()HC-()2Y(K,R)-() Series PropellersRepetitive
Hartzell propeller hubs may crack, causing blade separation and loss of aircraft control. The AD requires initial and repetitive eddy current inspections of the front cylinder half for cracks, removal of cracked hubs from service, or installation of improved design hub (suffix SN A or B) as terminating action.
Engine models named IO-360 series, O-360 series
Read the AD in the Federal RegisterShow 8 older
AD2006-06-16Effective Apr 27, 2006Lycoming Engines (Formerly Textron Lycoming) AEIO-360, IO-360, O-360, LIO-360, and LO-360 Series Reciprocating EnginesOne-time
Certain crankshafts in Lycoming AEIO-360, IO-360, O-360, LIO-360, and LO-360 series engines can fail, causing total engine power loss and possible aircraft loss. This AD requires replacement of affected crankshafts.
Engine models named IO-360, O-360
Read the AD in the Federal RegisterAD2005-19-11Effective Oct 21, 2005Lycoming Engines (Formerly Textron Lycoming) AEIO-360, IO-360, O-360, LIO-360, LO-360, AEIO-540, IO-540, O-540, and TIO-540 Series Reciprocating EnginesOne-time
Certain Lycoming 360 and 540 series engines have experienced crankshaft failures that could cause total engine power loss and in-flight engine failure. This AD requires replacement of affected crankshafts.
Engine models named IO-360, O-360
Read the AD in the Federal RegisterAD2004-10-14Effective Jun 25, 2004Lycoming Engines (Formerly Textron Lycoming), Direct-Drive Reciprocating EnginesRepetitive
Crankshaft gear retaining bolts may loosen or fail on certain Lycoming direct-drive reciprocating engines, potentially causing sudden engine failure. The AD requires removal of existing gear retaining bolts and lockplates from service, installation of new hardware, and inspection of crankshaft gear installation after propeller strikes, sudden stoppages, or overhaul.
Engine models named O-320 series, O-360 series
Read the AD in the Federal RegisterAD2003-14-03Effective Aug 14, 2003Textron Lycoming Fuel Injected Reciprocating EnginesRepetitive
Certain Textron Lycoming fuel-injected engines equipped with Crane/Lear Romec rotary fuel pumps are prone to fuel leakage from the pump relief valve, which could cause engine failure or fire. Owners must inspect pump relief valve attaching screws for proper torque and replace the affected fuel pump at or before engine overhaul with a new design pump having enhanced leak resistance.
Engine models named IO-360
Read the AD in the Federal RegisterAD2002-12-07Effective Jul 3, 2002Textron Lycoming Reciprocating EnginesEmergency AD
Oil can leak between the converter plate and accessory housing on certain Lycoming engines, potentially causing complete engine oil loss, engine seizure, and fire. This AD requires replacement of the oil filter converter plate gasket or kit, inspection of the oil filter base for leakage, and eventually installation of an improved gasket or kit to eliminate the need for repetitive replacements.
Engine models named IO-360-A1B6D, IO-360-A1D6D, IO-360-A3B6D, IO-360-A3D6D, IO-360-C1E6D, IO-360-J1A6D, IO-360-J1AD, O-320-H1AD, O-320-H1BD, O-320-H2AD, O-320-H2BD, O-320-H3AD
Read the AD in the Federal RegisterAD2000-04-10Effective Mar 9, 2000Hoffmann Propeller Co. HO27( ) and HO4/27 Series PropellersRepetitive
Propeller mounting bolts may lose torque due to operating conditions and environmental factors, risking propeller separation. The AD requires installing improved mounting bolts, torquing them to a higher value, flying the airplane once, and retorquing as needed.
Engine models named O-360 series
Read the AD in the Federal RegisterAD98-01-06Effective Feb 13, 1998Precision Airmotive Corporation CarburetorsRepetitive
Precision Airmotive carburetors with two-piece venturis may have loose or missing primary venturis, or fuel flow disruption when a one-piece venturi is installed, causing loss of power or forced landings. Owners must either perform repetitive inspections of two-piece venturis annually, or optionally install a one-piece venturi with a new fuel nozzle as a terminating action.
Engine models named O-320 series
Read the AD in the Federal RegisterAD97-15-11Effective Aug 12, 1997Avco Lycoming and Textron Lycoming Reciprocating EnginesOne-time
Certain Lycoming reciprocal engines may have defective piston pins that could fail and cause engine failure. Affected engines must be removed from service and replaced with serviceable parts according to the referenced service bulletin.
Engine models named IO-360, O-320, O-360
Read the AD in the Federal RegisterEngine ADs name an engine model family used on some Musketeers; check the exact model and serial. 4 more apply by part number only and are not listed.
Accident history
403 U.S. accidents involving the Musketeer since 1995, 68 of them fatal, with 123 fatalities. Homebuilt aircraft excluded. Counts, not rates: they follow fleet size, hours flown and how the airplane is used.
- Ground30
- Takeoff and climb12424
- Cruise5813
- Maneuvering2316
- Approach and descent7713
- Landing1161
- Other or unknown21
Phase of the event the NTSB recorded as defining the accident.
- 1995–199910818
- 2000–20047618
- 2005–2009648
- 2010–20144710
- 2015–2019505
- 2020–2024479
- 2025–2026110
2026 is year to date. Investigations can take a year or more to reach the data.
NTSB cause findings, 2008–2026 · share of 172 accidents with findings
- 52% Personnel issues
- 31% Aircraft performance and control
- 25% Aircraft systems, powerplant and structure
- 10% Environmental issues
- 7.6% Not determined
Most frequent cause findings
- Aircraft controlPersonnel issues32
- Directional control: not attained/maintainedAircraft performance and control21
- Decision making/judgmentPersonnel issues12
- Use of equip/systemPersonnel issues12
- Fuel: fluid managementAircraft systems, powerplant and structure10
- Incorrect action performancePersonnel issues8
- Preflight inspectionPersonnel issues7
- Airspeed: not attained/maintainedAircraft performance and control7
- Landing flare: not attained/maintainedAircraft performance and control6
- InstallationPersonnel issues5
Findings about systems and powerplant
- Fuel: fluid managementFluids10
- Fuel: fluid levelFluids4
- Fuel selector/shutoff valve: incorrect use/operationFuel system4
- Recip engine power section: failureEngine (reciprocating)2
- Fuel selector/shutoff valve: not used/operatedFuel system2
- Recip engine power section: fatigue/wear/corrosionEngine (reciprocating)2
- TE flap control system: not used/operatedFlight control system1
- Fuel distribution: incorrect service/maintenanceFuel system1
Wording is the NTSB’s. An accident can carry findings in several categories. Read individual investigations in the NTSB’s CAROL database.
What gets written up
258 reports · 1995–2026
The ten systems with the most service difficulty reports, by FAA system code (JASC). Fewer than 200 reports were filed on the Musketeer in 2016–2025, so read these as long-run patterns.
85Reciprocating Engine Cylinder Section135.0%1
Parts most often named Cylinder (5) · Valve (2) · Pin Plug (1) · Piston (1)
AFTER TAKE OFF, PILOT HEARD A LOUD BANG FROM THE ENGINE FOLLOWED BY VIBRATION AND LOSS OF POWER. SUCCESSFULLY RETURNED TO THE AIRPORT AND LANDED WITHOUT INCIDENT. INSPECTION OF THE ENGINE REVEALED THE NR 1 CYLINDER HAD CRACKED APPROXIMATLY 75% OF THE CIRCUMFERENCE WHERE THE HEAD AND BARREL MEET. RECORDS INDICATE THE CYLINDER HAD BEEN OVERHAULED ON 10/20/2011. THE CYLINDER WAS INSTALLED ON 6/19/2014. THE CYLINDER ACCUMULATED 73.1 HOURS BEFORE THE FAILURE.
(CAN) LORS D`UN INSPECTION DE 100 HRS, LE TECHNICIEN D`ENTRETIEN A DECOUVERT DU METAL (BRASSE) DANS LE FILTRE A L`HUILE. APRES INVESTIGATION, UNE "PUSH ROD TUBE" DE LA VALVE D`ADMISSION A ETE TROUVE DEFORME. APRES ANALYSE, LE RESSORT INTERIEUR DE LA VALVE A ETE TROUVE CASSE EN PLUSIEURS MORCEAUX CE QUI A PROVOQUE LE BLOCAGE DE LA SOUPPAPE D`ADMISSION CAUSANT AINSI LA DEFORMATION DE LA "PUSH ROD TUBE". (TC# 20101117001)
(AUS) ENGINE CYLINDERS (4OFF) SEVERELY ERODED ON EXHAUST FLANGES. GASKETS LEAKING AND CAUSING BLOW-BY. ENGINE, ENGINE COMPONENTS AND FIREWALL CORRODED DUE TO EXHAUST GAS CONTAMINATION. AIRCRAFT HAD COMPLETED 20.7 HOURS SINCE LAST PERIODIC INSPECTION.
32Landing Gear Retract/Extend System114.3%1
Parts most often named Switch (1) · Swivel Rod (1) · Brush Set (1) · Side Brace (1)
THE RT MLG UP-LOCK ACTUATOR FAILED AND WOULD NOT RELEASE THE LANDING GEAR UP-LOCK HOOK, PREVENTING THE RT MLG FROM EXTENDING.
THE AIRCRAFT TOUCHED DOWN UNEVENTFUL. DURING ROLLOUT, THE NOSE GEAR COLLAPSED ABOUT 1500 FT AFTER TOUCHDOWN. THE DRAG BRACE FAILED AT THE YOKE WHERE IT ATTACHES TO THE NOSE GEAR. (K)
DURING AN ANNUAL INSPECTION, A CRACK WAS DISCOVERED ON THE MLG UPPER SIDE BRACE WELD ASSEMBLY NEAR THE AFT ATTACH POINT.
79Engine Oil Temp. Regulator114.3%0
Parts most often named Valve (9) · Bypass Valve (2)
WHILE COMPLYING WITH LYCOMING SB 518A, FOUND CRIMP NUT LOOSE AS SHOWN IN STEP 2 OF BULLETIN. ALSO, FOUND THERMO BELLOWS DAMAGED. CRIMP NUT LOOSE DUE TO POOR DESIGN.
WHILE COMPLYING WITH LYCOMING SB 518, FOUND CRIMP NUT LOOSE AS SHOWN IN STEP 2 OF BULLETIN. SUBMITTER SUGGESTS CRIMP NUT LOOSE DUE TO POOR DESIGN.
WHILE COMPLYING WITH LYCOMING SB 518A FOUND CRIMP NUT LOOSE AS SHOWN IN STEP 2 OF BULLETIN. SUBMITTER SUGGESTS CRIMP NUT LOOSE DUE TO POOR DESIGN.
85Reciprocating Engine Power Section103.9%0
Parts most often named Rod Bearing (2) · Crankcase (2) · Camshaft (1) · Piston Ring (1)
IN-FLIGHT CATASTROPHIC FAILURE, DURING INITIAL CLIMB, ENGINE RAN ROUGH, QUIT PRODUCING POWER AND STOPPED. ACFT LANDED IN A FIELD. NO DAMAGE INCURRED.
OPERATOR COMPLAINED OF ENGINE SURGING 25 RPM OF 2400 RPM. STATED THAT THE NR 4 CYL WAS 70 DEGREES COLDER THAN THE OTHER CYLINDERS. LANDED AND CHECKED OIL. FOUND OIL ON TOP OF THE ENGINE, SUSPECTED TO COME FROM THE SPLIT CASE. FOUND NO DAMAGE TO EXTERIOR OF ENGINE. FOUND OIL BLACK JUST AFTER BEING CHANGED 7 HRS BEFORE. OIL HAD A STRONG ODOR OF COMBUSTION. BOTH SPARK PLUGS WAS OIL FOULED. REMOVAL OF THE NR 4 CYL REVEALED THE OIL SCRAPPER RING AND SECOND COMPRESSION RING HAD BROKEN. CAUSE UNKNOWN.
556 HOURS SINCE MAJOR OVERHAUL, CAMSHAFT AND LIFTERS SPALLED AND CORROSION IS EVIDENT. ENGINE HAS BEEN OPERATED ON PHILLIPS XC 20W50 OIL.
55Horizontal Stabilizer Structure103.9%0
Parts most often named Hinge (2) · Spar (2) · Stabilator (2) · Bolt (2)
UPON REMOVAL OF THE HORIZONTAL STABILATOR FOR BEARING REPLACEMENT, A CRACK WAS NOTED COMING OUT FROM UNDER THE LEFT HINGE BRACKET THAT IS RIVETED TO THE SPAR OF THE HORIZONTAL STABILATOR. (K)
THE PAINT WAS CRACKED AROUND THE HINGE PLATE ON THE RT SIDE. A FINGERNAIL WOULD GO UNDER A COUPLE OF THE RIVETS. WHEN THE RIVETS WERE DRILLED OUT, SEVERAL SPUN AND BROKE BEFORE THE BIT WENT THROUGH. THE BACK SIDE OF THE HINGE PLATES WAS RUSTED AND BLACK GALLING APPEARED ON THE ALUMINUM UNDERNEATH INDICATING MOVEMENT. SUBMITTER STATED THIS IS A 25-HOUR AD INSPECTION THAT IS DIFFICULT TO ASSESS UNTIL REMOVED. (X)
(CAN) UPON REMOVAL OF STABILATOR ACTUATING TUBE BALANCE WEIGHT, IMPACT DAMAGE TO THE ATTACHMENT BOLT WAS FOUND. DAMAGE APPEARED TO BE CAUSED BY REPETITIVE IMPACT RESULTING FROM BALANCE WEIGHT STRIKING THE MICARTA STOP BLOCK. AIRCRAFT TT: 2,033 HOURS.
61Propeller Blade Section93.5%1
Parts most often named Blade (7) · Block (1) · Propeller (1)
(AUS) PROPELLER PITCH CHANGE BLOCKS CRACKED. PITCH CONTROL FORK WORNEXCESSIVELY. HUB PRELOAD PLATE DAMAGED DUE TO PREVIOUS FOREIGN OBJECT STRIKE.
(CAN) DIMENSIONAL CHECK, FOUND PROPELLER TO BE JUST UNDER MINIMUM ALLOWABLE THICKNESS AT THE 34.20 INCH STATION. PROPELLER RETIRED FROM [S/N removed].
(CAN) DUE TO CORROSION OF THE PROPELLER BLADES, CAMBER AND FACE GRINDING IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE SENSENICH MAINTENANCE MANUAL WAS CARRIED OUT.
53Fuselage Miscellaneous Structure93.5%0
Parts most often named Frame Angle (8) · Channel (1)
FOUND COROSION AT FORWARD ATTACH POINT OF CHANNEL 169, 520000-91, AT FS 132 WHERE AIR DUCT COMES THROUGH CHANNEL - ATTACH POINT COMPLETELY GONE. ALSO, FOUND CORROSION AT VARIOUS POINTS ON FUSELAGE (WHERE FRESH AIR DUCT TOUCHES FUSELAGE).
INSPECTION FOUND CRACKING IN FRAME ANGLE WHICH MOUNTS INSTRUMENT PANEL TO FUSELAGE AND CRACKS IN ADJACENT CHANNEL AND FUSELAGE SKIN. SUSPECT CRACKING BECAUSE OF LANDINGS MADE IN TRAIING AIRCRAFT. SUBMITER SUGGESTED CLOSE INSPECTION OF STRUCTURE MOUNTING INSTRUMENT PANEL EVERY 100 HOURS OR ANNUALLY.
74Magneto/Distributor83.1%2
Parts most often named Rotor (3) · Magneto (2) · Housing (1) · Coil (1)
(CAN) DURING A FLIGHT AIRCRAFT LOST THE USE OF A MAGNETO. AFTER OPENING THE ENGINE COVER, THE TECHNICIAN NOTICED THAT THE FLANGE OF THE MAGNETO WAS HANGING. A LARGE QUANTITY OF METAL FILINGS HAS BEEN FOUND IN THE OIL FILTER. (TC# 20180808017)
(CAN) AFTER STARTING THE ENGINES, A CHECK OF THE MAGNETOS REVEALED THE RIGHT HAND MAGNETO WAS DEAD. THE AIRCRAFT WAS TAKEN TO MAINTENANCE AND THE TECHNICIAN FOUND THE CAM BROKEN.
DISASSEMBLED RT MAGNETO. FOUND EXCESSIVE CARBON RESIDUE IN COIL AREA. FURTHER INVESTIGATION REVEALED THE ROTOR ARM ON GEAR ASSY HAD BECOME LOOSE ALLOWING APPROXIMATELY 30 DEGREE MOVEMENT SIDE TO SIDE. SUBMITTER RECOMMENDS 500-HOUR INSPECTION OF BLOCK AND GEAR ASSY IN FAA SAFETY RECOMMENDATION.
24DC Generator-Alternator72.7%0
Parts most often named Alternator (3) · Fan (1) · Rotor Coil (1) · Generator (1)
ALTERNATOR FAILED WHILE ACFT WAS IMC, VFR CONDITIONS ENCOUNTERED. AIRCRAFT LANDED WITHOUT INCIDENT. INVESTIGATION REVEALED ROTATING FIELD WAS ELECTRICALLY OPEN DOWN. STREAM OF SUD RINGS. PART TSO WAS ONLY 52 HOURS SINCE OVERHAULED. (X)
ALTERNATOR FAILED IN IMC. AIRCRAFT WAS LANDED GEAR UP. SUBSTANTIAL DAMAGE. NO INJURIES. INSTALLED NEW ALTERNATOR. OPS CHECKED OK. FAILED ALTERNATOR OVERHAUL. ON 11-15-96. INSTALLED 5-19-97.
GENERATOR WENT 'OFF LINE'. DISASSEMBLY FOUND BRUSH LEADS CUT AND FRAYED BY BRUSH HOLDERS. REAR BEARING FOUND LOOSE IN REAR HOUSING CAUSING ROTATIONAL VIBRATION WHICH CAUSED BRUSH LEADS TO HIT BRUSH HOLDERS.
61Propeller Spinner Section72.7%0
Parts most often named Bulkhead (6) · Spinner (1)
(AUS) PROPELLER SPINNER CRACKED IN SEVERAL PLACES. SPINNER APPEARS TO HAVE BEEN REPAIRED BY WELDING. THE QUALITY OF THE WELD REPAIRS IS VERY POOR WITH CRACKS EMANATING FROM THE WELDS. LAST PERIODIC INSPECTION 20.7 HOURS PREVIOUS. PERSONNEL/MAINTENANCE ERROR.
(AUS) PROPELLER SPINNER FORWARD BULKHEAD CRACKED IN SEVERAL PLACES. BULKHEAD APPEARS TO HAVE BEEN REPAIRED BY WELDING WITH THEQUALITY OF WELDS VERY POOR. CRACKS EMANATING FROM THE WELDS.AIRCRAFT HAD OPERATED FOR 20.7 HOURS SINCE THE LAST PERIODICINSPECTION. PERSONNEL/MAINTENANCE ERROR.
DURING PROPELLER REMOVAL, FOUND CRACKS AT EACH BOLT HOLE. BULKHEAD WAS INSTALLED WITH NEW A-4227-1 SHOULDER WASHERS AT INITIAL INSTALLATION 72 HOURS PRIOR. SUSPECT CRACKS DUE TO POOR DESIGN AND POOR MANUFACTURING.
Open a row to read what mechanics wrote. Tail and serial numbers are removed.
At the pre-buy
My pre-buy card · Musketeer
0 of 7 looked at
The components written up most often since 2011. Take this to the pre-buy and ask your inspector about each one; tap a mark to record what they found. Saved on this device only.
- Landing Gear Retract/Extend System
- Wing, Rib/Bulkhead
- Nose/Tail Landing Gear Strut/Axle
- Magneto/Distributor
- Reciprocating Engine Cylinder Section
- Fuel Control/Reciprocating Engines
- Propeller Blade Section
A starting point for the conversation with your inspector, not maintenance advice.
What buyers get caught by
The expensive surprises on any used airplane are missing logbooks, corrosion under paint, outstanding ADs, an engine near overhaul, and the same squawk written up again and again. The card lists where the Musketeer gets written up; the AD timetable below lists what the FAA requires.
Ask for the logbook entries that match each item. A repeated entry is a pattern, not a coincidence.
Alerts for the Musketeer
An email when a new airworthiness directive names the Musketeer, or when reports on it spike. Alerts are starting soon: leave your email and we’ll send a confirmation link before anything else. Unsubscribe anytime.
We store only your email and which pages you follow. We never share it.